Celebrity Justice

August 21, 2009

How Does Giants WR Plaxico Burress Get Two Years in Prison When Donte’ Stallworth Only Got 30 Days in Jail for DUI Manslaughter?

After posting a recent blog entry on NFL wide receiver Donte’ Stallworth’s 30 day jail sentence for the crime of DUI Manslaughter, I feel compelled to discuss the recent plea agreement that was entered into by New York Giants wide receiver Plaxico Burress. Facing a likely 3 1/2 year prison sentence, Burress pled guilty to one count of attempted criminal possession of a weapon, a lesser charge than the one he was facing after accidentally shooting himself in the thigh while inside the Latin Quarter nightclub in Manhattan in late November 2008.The firearm which Burress was carrying was not registered in the State of New York, or the State of New Jersey (where Burress lives). Burress previously had a Carrying a Concealed Weapon permit in the State of Florida; however, that license expired in May of 2008.

Unlike the favorable treatment that was received by Donte’ Stallworth during his DUI Manslaughter case in Miami-Dade County (as previously discussed in this blog on August 4, 2009), Burress certainly was not given any special and/or favorable treatment by the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office. In fact, his high-profile attorney, Benjamin Brafman stated “If Plaxico Burress were not a high-profile individual, there never would be a case.” Brafman also stated that, “If he were just John Q Public, he would have walked out of the club and he never would have been arrested.”

When comparing the two cases, it is obvious that Stallworth and Burress were not treated equally. In fact, aside from the fact that both cases involved NFL-star wide receivers, the only commonality between the two cases is that they both prove (once again) just how easy it is to ruin a very successful career, in a matter of seconds, when alcohol is involved and poor choices are made. Attorney Brafman called the case “a perfect example of how bad judgment can have very serious consequences.”

I couldn’t agree more.
Continue reading

August 20, 2009

Tampa Bay Buccaneer Aqib Talib Arrested in Pinellas County for Battery on Cab Driver

by Blake & Dorsten, P.A.

For all of you Tampa Bay Buccaneer fans out there…. this story has got to drive you crazy. Last year’s first round draft pick, Aqib Talib, who plays cornerback for the Bucs, was arrested early this morning for Battery and Resisting Arrest Without Violence after he allegedly struck a cab driver in the neck and ear while riding from a St. Petersburg club to a Tampa hotel.

For the complete story, check out today’s St. Petersburg Times article.

This is not the first time that Talib’s behavior has been called into question. In May, Talib was involved in a fight during a Bucs practice in which he hit his teammate Torrie Cox, as well as a bystander, with his helmet. Talib was actually trying to hit teammate Donald Penn. Cox, who was attempting to break up the fight, received multiple stiches in his face.Talib was also involved in a fight with then-teammate Cory Boyd at the NFL’s Rookie Symposium last year. Coincidentally, one of the topics discussed at the Symposium was “personal conduct.”

In college, at the University of Kansas, Talib reportedly tested positive for marijuana multiple times. This unfortunate news for the Bucs comes just days after Safety Tanard Jackson was suspended by the NFL for four (4) games for violating the league’s substance-abuse policy.
Continue reading

August 4, 2009

Was Justice Served in NFL Star Donte’ Stallworth’s DUI Manslaughter Plea Deal?

by Blake & Dorsten, P.A.

Every once in awhile, I like to chime in on a criminal case that has caught the attention of the media nationwide. Today’s question is this: Did Cleveland Browns wide receiver Donte’ Stallworth receive any special treatment in the handling of his recent DUI Manslaughter case in Miami, Florida?

For more information on this story, you can check out this article from the Miami Herald: Donte’ Stallworth gets a month in jail for DUI Death.

Dozens of DUI Manslaughter and traffic-related homicides are being handled. In most cases, the Defendant received a prison sentence of anywhere from ten (10) to fifteen (15) years (depending on the specific facts of each case as well as the Defendant’s prior criminal record). Looking back on my six (6) years with the State Attorney’s Office in Clearwater, it’s difficult to recall a DUI Manslaughter case with a similar sentence.

Therefore, we all need to ask ourselves these questions: “Why did this individual (Donte’ Stallworth) receive such a lenient sentence?” and “Was his celebrity status influential in obtaining this favorable plea offer?”

Like many other Crimes of Violence, the ultimate resolution of a DUI Manslaughter case can be driven by the victim and/or victim’s family or next-of-kin. In this case, the family of the deceased man that was running across the street to catch a bus made a specific request that the State Attorney’s Office resolve the criminal case quickly so that the entire family could get some closure.

However, the State of Florida had a very strong case against Stallworth. Stallworth’s blood-alcohol level after the crash was a .126, well above the legal limit of .08 in the State of Florida. Stallworth admitted to driving and flashing his lights, while driving in his black 2005 Bentley, at 50 mph in a 40 mph zone.

As for a defense, 59-year old construction crane operator Mario Reyes was not in a crosswalk when he tried to cross the busy MacArthur Causeway in Miami. However, the State doesn’t need to prove that Stallworth “caused” the acccident. The State only needs to prove that Stallworth’s drinking and driving “contributed” to the accident — an issue that would be very difficult to rebut based on the evidence that has been made public.

While Donte’ Stallworth was the recepient of a very lenient plea bargain and sentence, most people are not that lucky. The Blake & Dorsten, P.A., in Clearwater, aggressively defends those accused of Criminal Traffic Violations and has experience handling the most complicated and serious traffic offenses such as DUI Manslaughter, Vehicular Homicide, Leaving the Scene of an Accident Involving Death, Reckless Driving Causing Serious Bodily Injury and DUI Causing Serious Bodily Injury.

To view a short video with commentary on this case, check out the following from Newsy.com:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xUfTE2MIWl8

Continue reading